14 Comments
User's avatar
Niamh Celeste's avatar

I love the old stories. This is the history of the country of real people, not political types. I love it.

Paul Jackson's avatar

I like that, too. The details that emerge in these accounts of individuals and their lives are priceless. Like the scoreboard boys gouging Boston patrons for a "standing box." So good.

mary mustard's avatar

We think of the past as such a prim and proper place, but in many ways we are much more mannered than when people regularly threw bottles at poor performing infielders and stormed the field like they owned it.

Paul Jackson's avatar

Another quote from Tommy Leach that speaks to your comment:

"The fans were part of the game in those days. They’d pour right out onto the field and argue with the players and the umpires. Was sort of hard to keep the game going sometimes, to say the least."

Bill Southern's avatar

Candy LaChance? Sounds like a stripper, Paul. And, “City of Smoke”? Ouch, that hurts, man. Even with no “h” - we’re far less smoky than we used to be.

Paul Jackson's avatar

A lot of the writing made Pittsburg seem like Mordor, at least from the perspective of the "City of Culture." I'd never heard that one for Boston. I'm glad the city leaders brought back the "h". Silent letters are classy.

Baseball has its Babes, a few Candys, at least one Doll, and who knows what else. Probably not a "name" project I'll do, but the material is there.

Jeff's avatar

Love the fans all over the field. When I took a tour of Yankee Stadium (old one) they had us on the outfield dirt walking to the dugout. If they saw you bending down to get some dirt you got yelled at & probably tossed. Guess they wanted to sell you some instead. Of course.

I wish they would’ve kept Tessie instead of Sweet Caroline. They despise NY so intensely but they use a song from a guy born in Brooklyn. Doesn’t make sense to me. Maybe they don’t really hate us New Yorkers after all.

Far as baseball history goes I find it interesting how the game evolved… I just wish now they’d stop. They screwed up the game about as much as they could; but I’m sure next year they’ll find something else to botch.

Paul Jackson's avatar

Some of those early parks were designed such that one of the easiest ways to empty the park after a game was to have fans come on the field and depart through the outfield. My, how times have changed.

"Sweet Caroline" and "Dirty Water" don't make as much obvious sense to me, but that's probably part of the charm. These are "inside" traditions that the family loves that don't quite translate for outsiiders. If all the songs were about how great the Red Sox were it would feel to on-the-nose.

Glad you are enjoying the older stuff, Jeff. It's staying in the rotation!

Andy Moursund's avatar

Another great article, Paul. I'd read about this World's Championship before, but learning that Tessie was a parakeet.....that alone made the time spent reading it worthwhile. A parakeet!

One interesting tidbit for me is that the coverage of this Series was often placed in the context of other interleague exhibition games that were then an ongoing feature of early October. The 1904 Reach guide had a long and detailed writeup of each game of the World's Championship Series, but before it got around to that, it devoted three pages to all of the other "inter-league" series, such as those in St. Louis, Chicago, and Philadelphia. At the end of that article it added a composite "standings" that listed the number of victories by each team, divided by league. The final count was American League 35, National League 27.

Clark Griffith's New York Americans challenged McGraw's Giants to a series, but in a harbinger of things to come a year later, McGraw turned him down, and instead the Giants played a series of exhibition games against the likes of the Trenton YMCA. In fact on at least one occasion the NY Times duly reported on these other exhibition games while not even mentioning the Boston-Pittsburg series!

Paul Jackson's avatar

This is a great tidbit to include, Andy. I had it on my list as well but it didn't make the final cut. I was very surprised to learn that many other series were going on during the first World Series, as you lay out. What seems to be different here is the teams/leagues agreeing that this inter-league series would be meaningful in that the team that won could claim a victory--recognized by both leagues--that superseded winning a pennant. Otherwise, it's just another exhibition series when these were quite common at the end of the year.

I wonder if the ban on other games during the Series started when the leagues got more involved in the planning process after the year-without-a-series in 1904. This certainly is a book-length subject.

Andy Moursund's avatar

Jerry Lansche's 1989 book "The Forgotten Championships" is a history (with box scores) of all those postseason series, which in one case (Chicago) lasted all the way to 1942, and always took place at the same time as the regular World Series. OTOH the other intracity (and the intrastate Reds-Indians) series were all gone by the end of WW1. Checking randomly, those games also seemed to coincide with the Fall Classic.

Paul Jackson's avatar

Great research, Andy, I'm so glad you're offering some of it up here.

Jonathan Fox's avatar

The Dropkick Murphy’s version of “Tessie” is kind of a banger. With or without the inserted radio call of Joe Castiglione calling the final out of the 2004 World Series. As a Yankee fan, I rather prefer it without.

Paul Jackson's avatar

Agree. It was a killer track leading up to that Series. Since then it's been overexposed, but when it came out it was such a cool mash-up of old and new made by fans who knew their Boston sports.